WIR
Wirtgen
"Technology that pays"
Milling Excellence
Flagship Models: SP64, SP94, SP124
Paving Width: 6.0-12.5m
Max Power: 550 HP
Max Speed: 21 km/h
Technology: WITOS Paving
Premium Quality
CAT
Caterpillar
"Built for reliability"
Global Support
Flagship Models: AP655F, AP1055F, AP1555F
Paving Width: 6.0-15.0m
Max Power: 540 HP
Max Speed: 20 km/h
Technology: CAT Grade 3D
Industry Standard
VOL
Volvo CE
"Building tomorrow"
Efficiency Leader
Flagship Models: P6820D, P7820D, P8820D
Paving Width: 6.8-8.8m
Max Power: 480 HP
Max Speed: 18 km/h
Technology: Eco Mode
Eco Champion
BOM
Bomag
"Compaction expertise"
Compaction Focus
Flagship Models: BF600C, BF800C, BF1000C
Paving Width: 6.0-10.0m
Max Power: 450 HP
Max Speed: 16 km/h
Technology: IntelliPave
Compaction Pro
VOG
Vögele
"Excellence in paving"
German Engineering
Flagship Models: S1803-3i, S2003-3i, S2603-3i
Paving Width: 8.0-13.0m
Max Power: 520 HP
Max Speed: 19 km/h
Technology: ErgoPlus 3
Precision Master
DYN
Dynapac
"Compact by nature"
Compact Solutions
Flagship Models: F2500CS, F3500CS, F5500WS
Paving Width: 2.5-5.5m
Max Power: 350 HP
Max Speed: 15 km/h
Technology: DynaGrade
Compact King
TER
Terex
"Solutions that count"
Value Engineering
Flagship Models: CR462, CR552, CR662
Paving Width: 4.6-6.6m
Max Power: 320 HP
Max Speed: 14 km/h
Technology: SmartPave
Value Choice
RTX
Roadtec
"Built tough for you"
American Built
Flagship Models: RP195, RP270, RP390
Paving Width: 6.0-14.0m
Max Power: 510 HP
Max Speed: 17 km/h
Technology: TopCon 3D-MC²
Heavy Duty
AMM
Ammann
"Innovation in action"
Swiss Quality
Flagship Models: AFT270, AFT350, AFT500
Paving Width: 2.7-5.0m
Max Power: 380 HP
Max Speed: 16 km/h
Technology: Ammann Autopilot
Quality Focus
XCMG
XCMG
"Taking great responsibilities"
Cost Effective
Flagship Models: RP603, RP903, RP1253
Paving Width: 6.0-12.5m
Max Power: 470 HP
Max Speed: 18 km/h
Technology: X-Brain System
Budget Choice

Digitize Your Paver Fleet Inspections

Join 10,000+ construction operators using HVI App for comprehensive digital inspections, maintenance tracking, and compliance reporting.

120+ Point Inspections Photo Documentation Instant PDF Reports DOT Compliant

Performance Analysis Matrix

Comprehensive evaluation across key performance indicators (Score: 1-10)

Brand
Power & Performance
Paving Quality
Technology
Operating Efficiency
Reliability & Support
Value for Money
Wirtgen
9.5/10
9.5/10
9.5/10
8.5/10
9.0/10
7.0/10
Caterpillar
9.0/10
9.0/10
8.5/10
8.5/10
9.5/10
7.5/10
Volvo CE
8.0/10
8.5/10
8.0/10
9.5/10
8.5/10
8.0/10
Bomag
7.5/10
8.5/10
8.0/10
8.0/10
8.0/10
8.0/10
Vögele
8.5/10
9.5/10
9.0/10
8.5/10
8.5/10
7.0/10
Dynapac
7.0/10
8.0/10
7.5/10
8.5/10
8.0/10
8.5/10
Terex
6.5/10
7.0/10
6.5/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
9.0/10
Roadtec
8.0/10
8.0/10
7.5/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
8.0/10
Ammann
7.5/10
8.0/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
8.0/10
8.0/10
XCMG
7.0/10
7.0/10
6.5/10
7.0/10
6.5/10
9.5/10

Detailed Specifications Comparison

Brand/Model Paving Width Engine Power Hopper Capacity Max Speed Operating Weight Fuel Tank Price Range (USD)
Wirtgen SP64 6.0-10.0m 350 HP 15 tons 18 km/h 18.5 tons 550 L $650,000 - $750,000
Wirtgen SP94 9.0-14.0m 480 HP 20 tons 20 km/h 22.8 tons 650 L $850,000 - $950,000
Wirtgen SP124 12.0-18.0m 550 HP 25 tons 21 km/h 28.5 tons 800 L $1,200,000 - $1,400,000
CAT AP655F 6.0-12.0m 340 HP 14 tons 17 km/h 17.8 tons 520 L $580,000 - $680,000
CAT AP1055F 10.0-15.0m 450 HP 18 tons 19 km/h 21.5 tons 620 L $750,000 - $850,000
CAT AP1555F 15.0-18.0m 540 HP 22 tons 20 km/h 26.2 tons 750 L $1,100,000 - $1,250,000
Volvo P6820D 6.8-11.0m 320 HP 12 tons 16 km/h 16.5 tons 480 L $540,000 - $640,000
Volvo P7820D 7.8-12.5m 400 HP 16 tons 17 km/h 19.8 tons 580 L $680,000 - $780,000
Volvo P8820D 8.8-14.0m 480 HP 20 tons 18 km/h 23.1 tons 680 L $880,000 - $980,000
Bomag BF600C 6.0-10.0m 280 HP 12 tons 15 km/h 15.2 tons 450 L $520,000 - $620,000
Bomag BF800C 8.0-12.0m 350 HP 15 tons 16 km/h 18.5 tons 550 L $650,000 - $750,000
Bomag BF1000C 10.0-14.0m 450 HP 18 tons 16 km/h 22.8 tons 650 L $800,000 - $900,000
Vögele S1803-3i 8.0-12.0m 380 HP 16 tons 18 km/h 19.2 tons 580 L $720,000 - $820,000
Vögele S2003-3i 10.0-15.0m 450 HP 19 tons 19 km/h 23.5 tons 680 L $920,000 - $1,020,000
Vögele S2603-3i 13.0-16.0m 520 HP 22 tons 19 km/h 26.8 tons 750 L $1,150,000 - $1,250,000
Dynapac F2500CS 2.5-4.0m 180 HP 6 tons 12 km/h 8.5 tons 280 L $280,000 - $380,000
Dynapac F3500CS 3.5-5.5m 250 HP 8 tons 14 km/h 11.2 tons 350 L $380,000 - $480,000
Dynapac F5500WS 5.5-8.0m 350 HP 12 tons 15 km/h 14.8 tons 480 L $520,000 - $620,000
Terex CR462 4.6-7.0m 200 HP 8 tons 12 km/h 9.8 tons 320 L $320,000 - $420,000
Terex CR662 6.6-10.0m 320 HP 12 tons 14 km/h 15.5 tons 450 L $480,000 - $580,000
Roadtec RP195 6.0-12.0m 350 HP 14 tons 16 km/h 17.2 tons 520 L $590,000 - $690,000
Roadtec RP390 14.0-18.0m 510 HP 20 tons 17 km/h 25.8 tons 720 L $1,050,000 - $1,150,000
Ammann AFT270 2.7-4.5m 160 HP 7 tons 14 km/h 7.8 tons 250 L $290,000 - $390,000
Ammann AFT500 5.0-8.0m 380 HP 12 tons 16 km/h 16.5 tons 480 L $580,000 - $680,000
XCMG RP603 6.0-10.0m 280 HP 12 tons 16 km/h 15.8 tons 420 L $350,000 - $450,000
XCMG RP1253 12.5-16.0m 470 HP 18 tons 18 km/h 24.2 tons 680 L $720,000 - $820,000

Key Features & Technologies

Maximum Paving Width
Wirtgen SP124 leads with 18m maximum width capability, followed by CAT AP1555F and Roadtec RP390. Ideal for highway projects.
Fuel Efficiency Champion
Volvo P6820D with Eco Mode achieves 18% better fuel economy. Dynapac compact models excel in fuel consumption per square meter.
Technology Leader
Wirtgen WITOS Paving platform offers intelligent compaction, temperature monitoring, and automatic grade control with millimeter precision.
Best Value
Dynapac F2500CS offers exceptional value at $280,000-$380,000 for compact paving applications with proven reliability.
Paving Quality
Vögele S-series with ErgoPlus 3 system delivers superior mat quality with automated grade and slope control for premium finishes.
Temperature Control
Bomag IntelliPave system provides real-time temperature monitoring and compaction control for optimal asphalt density.
Screed Technology
CAT MobMat screed extensions provide quick width changes without tools, improving productivity on variable-width projects.
Operator Comfort
Volvo CE features industry-leading ROPS cab with excellent visibility, low noise levels, and ergonomic controls.
Service & Support
Caterpillar offers the most comprehensive global dealer network with 24/7 parts availability and certified technicians.
Environmental Compliance
All major brands offer Stage V/Tier 4 Final engines. Volvo & Ammann lead with hybrid-ready platforms.
Telematics Integration
CAT VisionLink, Wirtgen WITOS, Volvo CareTrack, and Bomag BOMAG Connect provide comprehensive fleet monitoring.
Lightweight Champion
Ammann AFT270 at 7.8 tons offers the best power-to-weight ratio for confined spaces and weight-restricted sites.

Expert Recommendations by Application

Highway & Interstate

Best Overall: Wirtgen SP124
Best Value: CAT AP1555F
Best Technology: Vögele S2603-3i

Highway paving requires maximum width capability (12m+), high production rates, and superior grade control. Focus on total cost per lane-mile and long-term reliability.

Urban Construction

Best Overall: Volvo P7820D
Best Maneuverability: Dynapac F3500CS
Quietest Operation: Ammann AFT350

Urban projects need compact machines with low noise levels, excellent maneuverability, and emissions compliance for residential areas.

Airport Runways

Best Overall: Vögele S2003-3i
Best Precision: Wirtgen SP94
Best Support: CAT AP1055F

Airport paving demands absolute precision, superior mat quality, and 24/7 support capability. Smoothness and density tolerances are critical.

Residential Streets

Best Overall: Dynapac F2500CS
Most Versatile: Terex CR462
Best Value: XCMG RP603

Residential paving benefits from compact, quiet machines with narrow width capability and low operating costs for smaller projects.

Parking Lots

Best Overall: Bomag BF600C
Most Efficient: Ammann AFT270
Best Technology: Volvo P6820D

Parking lot applications require good maneuverability, variable width capability, and integrated compaction for one-pass operations.

Industrial Sites

Best Overall: CAT AP655F
Most Robust: Roadtec RP195
Best Service: Bomag BF800C

Industrial paving requires heavy-duty construction, excellent parts availability, and ability to handle thick lifts in challenging conditions.

Enhanced with HVI App Digital Inspection Data

This analysis is enriched with real-world inspection data from the Heavy Vehicle Inspection (HVI) App, providing insights from 8,000+ paver inspections across global construction sites. The HVI App's digital inspection platform captures critical performance metrics, maintenance patterns, and operational efficiency data directly from the field.

Digital Inspections

Standardized 120+ point inspections with photo documentation and real-time reporting

Temperature Monitoring

Track screed temperature, hydraulic fluid temps, and engine performance metrics

Paving Analytics

Monitor mat quality, grade accuracy, and production rates for continuous improvement

Start Free Trial Book a Demo

Get HVI App
Inspection And Maintenance Management Software

Download Our App